A blog about creating value in your organization through supply chain excellence
by Jim Tompkins, CEO & President, Tompkins International, supply chain consulting

NRF Event Stresses Complexity of Supply Chain and Why Retail is at Crossroads

I just returned from the National Retail Federation’s Global Supply Chain Summit in Dallas. Many thanks to NRF for hosting this great event – a lot of new insights and many forward-thinking business leaders.

And I believe that the retail industry is beginning to understand the critical crossroads that they are facing and how huge a role the supply chain plays. In case you missed the summit, I wanted to share this  quick video clip from the keynote address, “Retail at a Crossroads,” and you can access the full presentation at http://www.tompkinsinc.com/events/2013/retail-crossroads-nrf-2013/

You can also watch this short video reviewing NRF’s diverse topics and how they show the complexity of today’s retail supply chains:

More Resources

From NRF’s blog about the event: “With Retail at a Crossroads, Supply Chain Value is Key”

More Retail Resources

No Comments

Amazon: Nothing Can Stop Them – Because They Personify Long-Term Thinking

amazon-nothing-can-stop-themAmazon’s numbers are out for the previous quarter, and since Amazon is the company to watch, investors and news outlets are putting their earnings reports under a microscope.

Some are saying the numbers were good, but others are disappointed and concerned about the short-term challenges ahead for Amazon (sales tax changes in the US and vendor costs/relations are among these).

But their growth continues. Nothing can stop Amazon – and one of the big reasons is because they think long-term. Instead of making decisions based on short-term factors like today’s stock price, lingering recession anxiety, or other excuses, they are making decisions that benefit them for the in the long run.

The list of innovations from Amazon continues to grow. CNBC reported that Amazon’s revenue grew by 22 percent in the past quarter, partly due to its innovations in the areas of digital content and cloud computing. The most recent is a move to creating original entertainment via Amazon Studios, and the technology to bring that entertainment into people’s homes through the production of a television set box for streaming video.

Along with these innovations, they are not afraid to experiment and continue to make investments in the right things: Their people, technology, their supply chain, and other operations, including a move to same-day delivery options.

The long-term is where real business value lies today. Watch this video for more on how Amazon avoids the plague of short-term thinking in business and how they get it right.


If you are having trouble viewing the video, please click here to view with an alternative video player. You can also access YouTube’s help pages here.

Photo Credit: Aurelijus Valeiša’s

No Comments

J. C. Penney’s Biggest Challenge: Leadership ‘Got Mud in its Hair’ by Running with Ron Johnson’s Strategy

mudraceBusiness leaders and retail media are still trying to wrap their heads around what happened at J.C. Penney after its board pushed out CEO Ron Johnson.

They had brought Johnson on to take advantage of his experience with creating the highly successful Apple Stores, as well as for his previous work in establishing new brands to sell at Target.

But after Johnson’s 17 months at Penney’s, the numbers were quite staggering. (See more on Johnson’s performance by the numbers and also compared to Amazon’s Jeff Bezos and Wal-Mart’s founder Sam Walton in this article.)

Not many retailers can come back from a loss of nearly $1 billion in annual revenue.

I was just asked an interesting question about this situation. It was after my keynote address at a supply chain conference at the Sam Walton College of Business at the University of Arkansas. An attendee wanted to know: “Did Penney’s board of directors get exactly what it asked for?”

The board certainly knew that the Apple retail experience was successful. They jumped right into Johnson’s new strategies of removing coupons and special deals that customers expected from the retail chain. But his new multi-tiered pricing scheme confused shoppers, and without the coupons they craved, customers fled.

It reminds me of a charity ‘mud run’ that I attended recently. At the end of the course, the participants could opt to jump and slide down a long muddy pathway. Many people took the plunge, but I heard some complaining afterward that they got mud in their hair. Well, what did they expect from sliding in the mud?

The board at Penney’s is now experiencing the same thing: They brought in Johnson and didn’t think during all the excitement that they might not be applying the right strategy to the company, and they got mud in their hair. They were not actually listening to their customers.

He came onboard to apply the Apple experience to shoppers at Penney’s, but what got lost in the shuffle was that customers want four things: Great prices, awesome selection, a good shopping experience, and convenience. Without addressing these first, new retail strategies –no matter how fresh and exciting – won’t go anywhere.

More Resources

Read more about my thoughts on Ron Johnson and comparing his retail strategy to Jeff Bezos of Amazon and Sam Walton, founder of Wal-Mart

Download this feature, “A Closer Look at Retail Strategy: What J.C. Penney’s Ron Johnson Did Wrong and What He Did Right.”

Photo Credit: Official US Navy Imagery

No Comments

Network Studies: What Are They Really Good For?

Sometimes topics come at you in coincidental waves. For instance, I’ve had several business leaders from different industries ask me about network studies and redesigns over the past month.

I wanted to share the feedback that I provided to these colleagues.

Q:  From a retail executive:  “I know a network study would help us minimize costs, but how can I be sure that it will grow revenue, since sales and revenue are what I need to focus on now?”

A:  By optimizing the location of distribution and fulfillment facilities, network studies do help grow the company’s revenue.  Fulfillment center location and order cycle time speed will drive sales and help grow your business – not just optimize costs.  However, most retailers are not getting this correlation between network design and revenue.  An improved service level will lead to improved sales and revenue.  So if you do get this correlation and react, then you are already ahead of your competition.

Q:  From a supply chain director in a consumer goods company:  “How can I justify a network study and potential redesign?  I have multiple priorities that it would need to cover to even get it approved.”

A:  Fortunately, the Tompkins Supply Chain Consortium has gathered data on why organizations conduct network studies.  The major factors or goals impacted by network studies, as cited by member companies, include:

  • Cost minimization
  • Customer service improvement
  • Profit maximization
  • Reduced capital outlay
  • Revenue maximization
  • Change / disruption minimization
  • Risk minimization

And from the answer to the retailer’s question in #1, we know that sales and revenue growth is also a great (although frequently overlooked) justification for network analysis and redesign.

Q:  Manufacturing executive in partnership with a logistics service provider (LSP): “How often do we need to do these studies? I don’t want to feel locked into a network design and I want to include my LSP, so how easy is this process, really?”

A:  Manufacturers that depend heavily on their LSP networks are especially vulnerable to becoming inflexible, expensive, and people-dependent within a few years. And much of this has become event-driven, such as with a merger or acquisition.  As noted in this WERC article, Network Design: No Time to Waste, LSP-driven networks have unique advantages that make it easier to evaluate how they are laid out and redesigned for flexibility.  The smartest companies are doing network studies every one or two years, or even better, continuously.

Jim

More Resouces

Consumer Products Manufacturers at a Crossroads

Supply Chain Networking Planning Transformed

Supply Chain Consortium Reports

Distribution Network Design

Photo Credit: Ben Salter

No Comments

Pay Attention to the Talent within Your Supply Chains in 2013

There’s a plethora of thought-provoking predictions about what’s in store for businesses in 2013, and this includes predictions about supply chains and logistics.

On this topic, editor Dan Gilmore and the Supply Chain Digest staff just presented a series of articles from supply chain gurus.

Among these gurus was Gene Tyndall of Tompkins International, who provided his views on the top five supply chain strategies for 2013. These strategies are all very important to apply, and you can see more about them here.

Gene’s fifth strategy in particular got me thinking about 2013 in terms of new supply chain talent and making your supply chains demand driven.

As Gene says in his predictions, “Wisdom, knowledge, innovation – none of this is possible without talented people. Many supply chains and business strategies are in need of transformation right now, as they have stagnated while companies shored up against the economic downturn. New supply chain technology and ideas went by the wayside far too often in previous years.”

Currently, supply chain managers, new graduates, and executives are behind on adapting tools and methods, such as demand-driven operations, that are the future of successful business and supply chain operations.

Success in 2013 (and beyond) is tied to the talents of people. Give the talented people at your company the tools and resources they need to implement their wisdom, knowledge, and innovation. Make this year one of transformation and get ready for dramatic performance gains for your company.

Resources

The NEW Demand-Driven Operations: Demand-driven supply chains allow companies in any industry to succeed in multichannel environments while keeping customer satisfaction levels high.

More predictions: Consumer Trends for 2013: An Interesting Year Ahead for Consumer Products Manufacturers

The best way for you and your supply chain talent to keep informed: Attend the Tompkins Supply Chain Leadership Forum, August 26-28 in Atlanta, GA – open to members of the Tompkins Supply Chain Consortium (free membership available).

Photo Credit: popofatticus

No Comments

After the Party: The Effects of Holiday 2012 Shopping Season Represent Major Tipping Point For Retailers

Holiday 2012 will be one of those major events that we look back on later and realize how profoundly important it was to our future business strategies.

Retailers are learning much from the holiday 2012 shopping season, especially as reports on sales become clearer. In fact, a recent survey from the National Retail Federation’s digital division, shop.org, says that online retailers in particular are learning lessons from 2012 that they can use next year. The survey found that online retailers are focusing on inventory management, fulfillment, and customer service as a few of their major 2013 priorities.

However, brick-and-mortar retailers are seeing a different trend for 2013: Store closings. Forbes recently reported that store closings were up in the last part of 2012.

So what exactly did retailers do as the 2012 holiday peak season approached?

The big story was how companies reacted to Amazon and its customer-pleasing innovations. Companies tried to mimic these innovations, or react to them for a short time with limited price matching or other promotions in an attempt to get customers into the store.

They gave away free shipping, returns, and promotions without knowing what the result would be; or they allowed competitors to set their prices through price matching offers, which destroyed their own cost structure.

Store closings will only occur more often if companies continue on this path. I believe we will see more bankruptcies in 2013-2014 than in any other two-year period.

Without supply chain excellence and execution, as well as putting strategy before structure, my prediction will come true as customers turn elsewhere for the best price, selection, convenience and experience.

For the complete run-down on holiday 2012 and why it was such a major event, listen to this podcast or read the text transcript.

More Resources

Podcast 94: Increased Store Closings After Holiday Peak Season Ends – How Do We Respond?

Consumer Trends for 2013: An Interesting Year Ahead for Consumer Products Manufacturers

“Did You Find Everything You Were Looking For?” What In-Store Customers Want

Photo Credit: jakerome

No Comments

Three Big Reasons Wal-Mart and Amazon’s Leaders Are Golden

Jeff Bezos, CEO of Amazon, was just named the National Retail Federation’s (NRF’s) Gold Award winner for 2012.

Although Bezos has been making headlines quite often for his many innovations, this one stands out. The NRF’s membership is made up mostly of traditionally brick-and-mortar stores, so by naming Bezos its retailer of the year, it really shows the extent of Amazon’s disruption of the retail industry.

2012 was a banner year for Amazon, and there is no doubt Bezos has shaken up the industry as major retail chains respond to the Amazon Effect. But this isn’t the first time the NRF has designated a force of great change as its retailer of the year.

In 1988, Sam Walton, founder of Wal-Mart, also won the Gold Award from NRF. And the comparisons between these two major innovators don’t end there. Both Walton and Bezos have been pioneers in these three major areas:

  • They both had a great retail strategy, built while totally focused on the customer.
  • They both defined their supply chain capabilities in response to their retail strategy.
  • They both applied technology to create major innovations and bring down prices for customers.

So why aren’t all companies doing these three things that have elevated both Bezos and Walton? A very good question.

Since both companies are also major competitors, it has been interesting to see how they respond to each other’s success through growth and innovation. While we know Walton’s legacy, where Bezos and Amazon will go is yet to be seen. Amazon’s growth and influence will continue, with new developments in same-day delivery and perhaps even brick-and-mortar stores.

But, wait: Wal-Mart isn’t just watching from the sidelines. I find it interesting that first it was Wal-Mart, then Amazon, and going forward, it’s a true battle of the titans.

See more on Amazon’s influence and future growth in this video: the Amazon Effect. http://www.tompkinsinc.com/amazon-effect/

More Resources

Photo Credit: etech

No Comments

A Question Heard Every Day in Retail Stores Could Soon Become Obsolete

“Did you find everything you were looking for today?” We frequently hear sales associates ask this as we’re checking out with our purchases. But could this common question soon become obsolete?

Yes, and here’s why. Recent mobile app development could eventually make finding everything you need as simple as using a GPS. Called indoor mapping, retailers use in-store apps and GPS mapping to help customers find what they need, turn-by-turn, while in a store.

The apps can also deliver ads in the form of coupons and buying incentives at the same time that customers are standing in front of products that they are considering purchasing. This can also help retailers with improving store layout (and hence, boost supply chain efficiency).

Indoor mapping is still a few years away from becoming a common tool, but some retailers are already testing it.  With a tool like this, customers should be able to easily find what they need. And this exactly is the kind of in-store experience that can bring in more customers, continually boost satisfaction levels, and turn them into repeat customers.

As retailers look for new ways to make in-store shopping more appealing, being able to help customers speed up the pace and find exactly what they need through indoor mapping is a great way to bring in customers and complement online offerings. Let’s keep an eye on this developing trend.

For more on enhancing the experience for in-store customers, read this new article.

Jim

More Resources

The Amazon Effect

The Amazon Effect: Why the Online Retailer is Every Company’s Biggest Competitor 

Infographic: 4 Reasons Why Amazon is Your Biggest Competitor this Holiday Season

Smartphones Are Quickly Becoming Shoppers’ Best Friends

Photo Credit: basykes

No Comments

Same-Day Delivery and Other Customer Expectations Spring From Your Supply Chain

Consumer expectations are changing as both online and in-store shoppers seek the best prices, convenience, selection and experience. What does this mean for your supply chain?

Getting the right products at the right time to the right destination affects all four of these consumer expectations. Price is affected by your distribution and transportation costs. Convenience can be improved by having a demand-driven supply chain in which inventory is responsive and stock-outs are a thing of the past. Large selections can only be supported through the right warehousing and distribution strategies.

Finally, a great experience both online and in-store ties back to many factors. For online retailers, this often meant fast shipping. Amazon is already moving toward large-scale, same-day delivery by building distribution centers close to major metropolitan areas. Amazon already has a formidable competitive presence in nearly all industries, which you can learn more about in this video, The Amazon Effect.

And now, Amazon’s major retail competitors are aware of the impact its many innovations could have on their survival. Wal-Mart Stores Inc. (Walmart) announced yesterday that they are testing same-day delivery programs in a few major metropolitan areas in the US.

So Instead of relying on distribution centers for delivery, the company will instead ship these orders from its stores for a $10 fee. Walmart is also trying to distinguish itself by doing things that Amazon can’t right now, including using its stores to take cash payments for orders placed online so that millions of customers without credit cards will come to their site to shop online.

Responding to customer demands and expectations is critical to business survival today. Understanding how to combine online and brick-and-mortar strategies to attract and keep customers will be a big driver to success. Walmart has seen it coming and is beginning to respond to The Amazon Effect.

In what new ways is your supply chain meeting customer expectations? What are your thoughts on combining online and in-store strategies?

More Resources

Whether retail, B2C or B2B, companies of every industry are at a crossroads. The reaction and response that you have now will decide your future. Learn more about this here.

No Comments

Smartphones Are Quickly Becoming Shoppers’ Best Friends

Have you used a mobile device to buy anything this month? According to a recent Nielson survey, over 45 million people used mobile apps to buy goods online in June 2012.

As huge as this number is, it makes sense if you just look around. Tablets and smartphones are everywhere today. We’re using them to play games, pay bills, check Twitter and Facebook, find movie reviews … the list is never-ending.

One thing that was particularly interesting to me about the Nielson survey results is that they only account
for people who shop using a mobile app. It doesn’t count folks who shopped using a mobile web browser. According to another Nielson survey about the 2011 shopping season, more consumers used a mobile web browser to shop than a mobile app, so there are likely many more transactions happening on mobile devices than reported in this latest survey. That makes that big number even bigger!

As delivery times are shortening and more retailers are offering free and next-day delivery, the convenience for consumers is becoming more and more appealing. Now don’t get me wrong. People still enjoy the experience of retail shopping in brick and mortar stores, but low prices, selection, and convenience are now available from home via their mobile devices.

And it turns out that those who use smartphones when they are out shopping are 14% more likely to make an
in-store purchase than those without smartphones (according to a recent TIME magazine article).

Retailers need to take note as the presence of omnichannel, multichannel, and e-commerce grows more and
more important to customers and new technology develops.  Online shopping is NOT the enemy of retail stores – it’s the accomplice that will actually save the physical store from extinction.

More Resources

Podcast: The Amazon Effect

The Omnichannel Retail Supply Chain

AmazonSupply Challenges Industrial Distributors to Respond to Changing Customer Preferences

Online Stores: Don’t Settle for ‘Good Enough’

Jim Tompkins on Twitter

Photo Credit: iphonepics

No Comments

Two Billion New Customers: Finally, Access to Selling to 1/3 of the World

Welcome to Michael Zakkour, a recognized expert on doing business in Asia, who brings this guest post on recent big retail news from India to the blog. Michael’s specialties include retail and consumer product development, supply chain and logistics for retail and branding and marketing in Asia. Michael shares his insight below:

In 2005, author James McGregor famously wrote his book, 1 Billion Customers:  Lessons from the Front Lines of Doing Business in China.  The first half of the title became business-world shorthand for the commercial and consumer product possibilities that companies around the world dreamed about when looking at China.

But what about the other 1 billion customers? You know, the English speaking democracy called India.

No one wrote a book about them because, although India is the world’s largest democracy, and one of the world’s largest consumer markets, it is also the world’s largest bureaucracy, featuring a system slowed to
inertia by red tape, the most fragmented retail market on Earth and a (in)famously closed door mentality about letting foreign retailers in.

The great news coming out of India on September 14 is that finally, at long last, India has cracked the door open and is inviting foreign retailers to ride the elephant, along with the dragon.

As the BBC reports, “Last year, the government suspended a similar plan after fierce opposition from its allies and political rivals. International firms such as Wal-Mart and Tesco will now be able to buy up to a 51% stake in multi-brand retailers. Analysts say the government has reintroduced the measure in an effort to revive a flagging
economy. Prime Minister Manmohan Singh said: ‘I believe that these steps will help strengthen our growth process and generate employment in these difficult times.’ “

‘Flagging’ is putting it mildly.  In the last year, growth in India has slowed from an average of 10% to as low as 6%. Foreign Direct Investment in India has dropped by 67%.

Now, this opening in India will come with many terms and conditions (such as openings only in cities of 1 million or more and a 30% sourcing-from-India requirement) but, again, it’s a start.

We have not been particularly bullish on India in the last five years, because it is still a fairly closed market. Opposition from dozens of politicians, parties and small business people have kept it that way.

In addition to this new measure, the Indian government is also opening up the aviation markets, as well as allowing diesel subsidies to lapse – these are more moves toward a more free market based economy.

This news is encouraging for brands, retailers, consumer products companies and the myriad companies who provide services in sourcing, manufacturing, distribution, warehousing, logistics and transportation.

Where Wal-Mart, Carrefour and Tesco go, so must go the supply chain infrastructure.

Finally, we can start writing a new book: Two Billion Customers: Selling to 1/3 of the World.

No Comments

The Amazon Effect and Your Supply Chain: It Matters

At the recent Supply Chain Leadership Forum in Denver, I started thinking about the heights that supply chain itself has risen to in the past decade.

Because it’s the vehicle that connects your strategy to your customers, supply chain has grown so important that it now commands the full attention of the C-level.

Remember when supply chain folks were some of the last in the company to be consulted about new products
or changes in strategies? Thankfully, those days are long gone as businesses find themselves at a X-Roads and needing to tackle the all-encompassing Amazon effect.

I kicked off the Forum by talking with supply chain executives about the Amazon Effect and how this is
one of the tipping points transforming how we view distribution networks, brick and mortar stores, and delivery. Amazon is going to take what they do best – the total customer experience, total convenience, total production selection, lower prices – and knock the ball out of the park with a store concept like the
world has never experienced before.

Jeff Bezos is a genius in many ways, but most definitely in his focus on the customer. If you want to
learn more about how Amazon is everyone’s competitor and how to handle Business at X-Roads, check out this podcast.

More Resources

The Amazon Effect: Listen to the podcast or read the text transcript

AmazonSupply: Not the End, But Industrial Distributors are at a Crossroads

Demand-driven Supply Chains: Getting it Right For True Value

Learn how to become a Supply Chain Consortium Member – Free and paid membership options available:

No Comments